top of page

A safeguarding question for grassroots sport: Are we really thinking about what we’re uploading to AI?

2 days ago
9 min read
A safeguarding question for grassroots sport: Are we really thinking about what we’re uploading to AI?

Marketing and sport. Two worlds of mine that increasingly collide. And I’m seeing a potentially concerning trend emerging, one that is rapidly gathering pace.


The amount of AI-generated content appearing across grassroots sport is rocketing.


From Player of the Match graphics and match reports to player profiles and social media posts, clubs and team managers are embracing AI to create content that looks great and saves valuable volunteer time.


And I completely understand the appeal.


But alongside this growing trend, I’m seeing something that I think deserves much more attention from a safeguarding perspective.


Actual photographs of children are being uploaded into AI tools, sometimes alongside their names, clubs and other personal information. I don’t think enough people understand what they are potentially sharing or what happens to that information once they press upload.


A photograph is more than just a photograph

When you upload an original photograph of a child into an AI tool, you may be uploading much more than the visible image.


The image file can contain embedded metadata (often referred to as EXIF data). Depending on the device and how the photograph has been processed, this could include:

  • The date and time the photograph was taken.

  • GPS location coordinates, potentially identifying where the photograph was taken.

  • The device or camera used.

  • Other technical information about the original image.


Combine that with information about the child’s club, team and playing activities and you potentially have a considerable amount of identifiable information in one upload.


Let’s put this into a real grassroots football example.

Imagine a football manager uploads a photograph of a 10 year old player and writes:


“Create a Player of the Match graphic for James, who plays for Super Rangers Juniors Under 11's.”


The AI tool receives the photograph and the information supplied alongside it.

It may process the child’s appearance, clothing, visible club badge and other identifying features. The original photograph may also contain embedded metadata, potentially including when and where it was taken.


The manager may simply be trying to create a nice graphic to celebrate a child’s performance. But the information being submitted goes beyond simply asking AI to design a graphic.


It potentially brings together a child’s face, first name, age group, football club, playing information and photographic data, all within one upload to an external technology provider.


That is a safeguarding consideration, not just a graphic design exercise.


But we already put children’s photographs on our public Facebook Page. So what’s the problem?

This is probably the first question many grassroots managers will ask, and it’s a fair one.


Most grassroots football clubs have public Facebook business Pages. They regularly publish actual photographs of children, celebrate performances and announce their Player of the Match.


They generally follow established safeguarding practice by using a child’s first name rather than their full name.


Parents have provided photography permissions, the club publishes the photograph and everyone understands the intended purpose: celebrating the child and promoting the club.


So why should uploading that same photograph to AI be any different?


Let’s look at what actually happens.


Example 1: Publishing on Facebook

A club publishes a photograph of a 10 year old player wearing their football kit, with the caption:


“Congratulations to James, our Player of the Match this weekend!”


The photograph is visible on the club’s public Facebook Page. People can view it, share it, comment on it and potentially download it.


Facebook processes the image under its own privacy and data-use policies.


Meta also has policies allowing certain publicly shared content from adult accounts to be used for AI development. Meta says it does not use information from accounts belonging to people under 18; however, that is distinct from public content shared by an adult account that happens to feature a child.


There are risks here.


Public photographs can be copied, redistributed and used beyond the club’s original intention. Public posting is not risk-free.


Example 2: Uploading the same photograph to an AI tool

Now imagine the team manager takes that exact photograph and uploads it to an AI tool, writing:


“Create a Player of the Match graphic for James, who plays for Super Rangers Juniors U11's.”


Something different has happened.


The manager has now submitted the actual image file to another technology provider.


The AI tool processes the image to understand its visual content and respond to the request. This may include analysing the child’s appearance, football kit, club badge and other visible identifying features.


The accompanying information also tells the provider the child’s first name, age group and club.


The original image may contain embedded metadata, potentially including the date, time and GPS location of the photograph, depending on the device and how the image has been processed.


The image and conversation may be stored under the provider’s retention policies. Depending on the account type and settings, submitted content may also be eligible for use in model improvement.


This does not mean the AI automatically learns or remembers James’s identity, makes his photograph publicly searchable or uses every uploaded image to train its models.


But the club has introduced another organisation, another purpose for processing and another set of data-handling arrangements.


And that is the difference we need people to understand.


Why does this matter if the photograph is already public?

Because making a photograph public for one purpose does not mean we should assume every subsequent use is appropriate.


A parent agreeing to their child’s photograph appearing on a club’s Facebook Page does not automatically mean they have agreed to that photograph being submitted to an AI provider.


The club should consider whether the new use is covered by its privacy information and lawful basis for processing. If it relies on consent, that consent must be specific and informed about the proposed use.


There is also a simple question of necessity.


If the manager can create an excellent Player of the Match graphic using an AI-generated illustration, a silhouette or a template, why upload an actual photograph of a child at all?


We should not introduce additional processing of children’s identifiable information when it isn’t necessary to achieve the result.


What about parental consent and GDPR?

This is arguably the most important part.


Most clubs have some form of parental photography consent. Parents agree to photographs being taken and used for club communications, websites and social media.


But consent needs to be understood in the context of the specific purpose for which personal information is being used.


Under UK GDPR, where an organisation relies on consent as its lawful basis, that consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous.


Parents need to understand what they are agreeing to.


Consent to take and publish a photograph on a club’s Facebook Page is not automatically consent to upload that photograph to an external AI provider for image processing and potentially product improvement.


These are different purposes and potentially different data-processing arrangements.


If a club wants to use identifiable children’s photographs in AI tools, it should not simply rely on its existing social media photography permission.


It needs to assess the proposed use separately, provide clear privacy information and establish an appropriate lawful basis.


Where consent is the chosen basis, it must be specific and informed about the AI use, including the provider and relevant data-handling arrangements.


Parental permission alone does not remove the club’s wider responsibilities under UK GDPR and safeguarding guidance.


Children charities also have a view.

The NSPCC has published specific guidance for sports clubs on photography, filming and the use of AI involving children's images.


Its central message is that clubs do not necessarily need to stop taking or sharing photographs of children, but they must take greater care over how images are collected, stored, shared and used with AI.


Key points from the NSPCC guidance

  1. Consent must be informed. Children and parents should understand why photographs are being taken, where they will be shared, who may see them and how long they will be kept. A child should also be happy for their photograph to be taken.

  2. Consent to publish is not consent to use AI. Agreeing to have a photograph taken or published does not automatically mean agreeing to have it altered or processed using AI tools.

  3. Clubs should control the use of AI. Staff, volunteers and suppliers should not upload children's images to AI, face-editing, background-removal or image-enhancement tools unless the organisation has checked and approved the tool.

  4. Understand what happens to uploaded images. Uploading a photograph may send it to another company, create additional copies or allow the provider to use it for AI training.

  5. Consider whether an image is actually needed. Clubs should think about whether they need a photograph at all and whether they could use action shots, pictures from behind, group photographs or illustrations instead.

  6. Have clear policies and procedures. Clubs should have a photography and filming policy, an AI safe-use policy, appropriate risk assessments and clear rules for staff and volunteers.


What should grassroots teams do?

I’m not suggesting we stop using AI. Quite the opposite.


Let’s continue producing Player of the Match graphics, match reports, player profiles and celebrating our young players.


But we can do this without uploading actual children’s photographs and identifiable personal information.

  • Use AI to write match reports without including children’s personal details.

  • Use generic illustrations, avatars or silhouettes for graphics.

  • Create player profiles using anonymised information.

  • Use AI to design graphics and templates, then add approved photographs separately through the club’s normal, authorised processes.

  • Check the AI provider’s data policies and your club’s safeguarding and data protection procedures.


The message is simple.

I genuinely don’t believe most grassroots managers are doing this with bad intentions.


They want to celebrate their players, recognise achievements and make life easier for volunteers.


But AI is still a huge knowledge gap for many people.

People understand Facebook. They understand publishing a photograph on their club’s Page, using a first name and celebrating a player’s performance.


They don’t necessarily understand that uploading that actual photograph into an AI tool is a different activity, potentially involving image analysis, data processing, storage and model improvement.


Just because we have made a child’s photograph public for one specific purpose doesn’t mean we should automatically submit that same photograph to another organisation, for another purpose, under a completely different set of data-handling arrangements.


We need to stop treating these activities as interchangeable.


Let’s embrace AI in grassroots sport, but let’s understand what we’re uploading, where it’s going and what we’re potentially giving permission for.

Convenience should never come before safeguarding.


Further reading and sources

NSPCC Child Protection in Sport Unit – AI and images of children in sport


NSPCC – Photography and filming children


Information Commissioner’s Office – How do we ensure lawfulness in AI?


Information Commissioner’s Office – Transparency and AI


Meta – Building AI Technology for the UK in a Responsible & Transparent Way


The FA – Safeguarding in the digital world






















The world of marketing has undergone a seismic shift in the last decade, pivoting from traditional mediums to a digital-first approach. Digital transformation in marketing is no longer a choice but a necessary adaptation to the evolving consumer landscape. In this context, embracing digital transformation means reimagining how businesses engage with customers, optimize processes, and utilize data for growth.

The New Digital Marketing Landscape

Digital transformation has ushered in an era where online presence, interactive customer engagem


ent, and data analytics have become the cornerstone of marketing success. With the proliferation of digital channels, businesses can now connect with customers in a multitude of ways - from social media to mobile apps, to AI-driven personalization.

Integrating Digital Strategies

A digital-first marketing strategy encompasses various elements, each integral to the digital transformation journey:

1. Customer-Centric Online Experience

Creating a seamless and intuitive online experience is crucial. This involves designing user-friendly websites, ensuring mobile responsiveness, and providing consistent and personalized interactions across all digital touchpoints.

2. Data-Driven Decision Making

Harnessing the power of big data and analytics allows marketers to gain insights into customer behavior, preferences, and trends. Leveraging this data leads to more informed decisions and more targeted marketing efforts.

3. Content is King

The digital age confirms that content reigns supreme. High-quality, engaging content drives SEO, encourages social shares, and provides value to the customer, thereby fostering loyalty and brand trust.

4. Automation and AI

Marketing automation and artificial intelligence have transformed how businesses approach tasks like customer segmentation, lead generation, and personalized communication. AI can predict customer behavior and automate responses, making marketing efforts more efficient and effective.

5. Omnichannel Presence

Customers expect to interact with brands across various channels seamlessly. An omnichannel strategy provides a unified customer experience, whether in-store, on a website, or through social media platforms.

6. Social Media Engagement

Social media platforms are no longer just for networking. They have become vital channels for


marketing, providing a space for businesses to engage with customers, showcase their brand personality, and even sell their products directly.

7. Adaptable and Agile Methodologies

The fast-paced digital market requires marketing strategies that are flexible and can quickly adapt to changes. Agile methodologies enable businesses to iterate their marketing efforts rapidly, testing what works and refining their approach continuously.

The Role of Leadership in Digital Transformation

Successful digital transformation in marketing begins at the top. Leaders must set a clear vision, commit to the necessary investments in technology and talent, and foster a culture that embraces change and innovation.

Overcoming the Challenges

Despite the clear benefits, the road to digital transformation can be fraught with challenges:

  • Resistance to Change: Employees may be resistant to replacing traditional methods with digital solutions.

  • Skill Gaps: There is a need for continuous learning and development to keep up with digital trends and technologies.


Integration Issues: Incorporating new digital tools with existing systems can sometimes be complex and costly.

Conclusion

Embracing digital transformation in marketing is not merely about adopting new technologies but about rethinking strategies to deliver value in a digital-first world. It's about being more proactive, predictive, and personalized in your marketing efforts. By integrating digital strategies, focusing on data, and fostering an adaptable culture, businesses can unlock unprecedented opportunities for growth and customer engagement in the digital age. As consumer behaviors continue to shift online, the importance of digital transformation in marketing will only intensify, making it essential for businesses to innovate or risk obsolescence.


bottom of page